15 Best Creamy Pasta Recipes

Creamy pasta sauces are the ultimate comfort food in my opinion, and these are the 15 very best recipes on The Burnt Butter Table. From silky garlic Parmesan sauces and rich, mushroom packed favorites to bright lemon pastas, spicy chorizo, and herby pesto, this collection covers all creamy pasta bases.

Each recipe is well tested, full of flavor, and written with all my tips and tricks to help you get a silky, glossy sauce every time.

Whether you want a super quick weeknight dinner or something a little indulgent, these creamy pasta recipes come together beautifully every time and I'm sure you are about to find a few new favorites.

White Pasta Sauce

A silky garlic-Parmesan cream sauce that comes together in minutes and clings beautifully to any pasta shape. The perfect base recipe when you want something fast, comforting, and foolproof.

Make This Recipe

Fettuccine in a creamy sauce with golden brown sliced chicken on top. Fresh rosemary leaves and lemon zest sprinkled on top.

Creamy Chicken Pasta

The most popular recipe on my whole site! Tender, golden chicken is tossed through a glossy garlic cream sauce brightened with lemon. It’s rich, comforting, and one of the most reliable weeknight pastas you can make.

Make This Recipe

White plate with rigatoni pasta in a creamy chorizo sauce. Fork resting in.

Creamy Chorizo Pasta

Smoky chorizo and a punchy tomato cream sauce bring big flavor with minimal effort. Bold, vibrant, and ready in no time! This one always surprises people with how good it is.

Make This Recipe

Creamy Tomato Pasta

A luscious pink sauce made with tomato paste, cream, parmesan, and lemon for just the right tang. Silky, bright, and perfect when you can’t decide between tomato or creamy.

Make This Recipe

Fry pan with orecchiette in a creamy mushroom sauce on a bench top.

Creamy Mushroom Pasta

Golden, sautéed mushrooms in a deeply savoury, restaurant worthy cream sauce. Earthy, rich, and incredibly satisfying, a vegetarian favorite!

Make This Recipe

White plate with busiate pasta in a creamy pesto sauce. Fresh basil leaves on top and a fork resting in.

Creamy Pesto Pasta

Herby basil pesto meets a velvety cream sauce for a quick, flavor packed dinner. It’s fresh, vibrant, and a little different from your usual creamy pastas.

Make This Recipe

Creamy Salmon Pasta

Flaky salmon sits in a light, silky sauce with lemon and capers to balance the richness. Elegant but fast, and such a good way to make pasta feel special.

Make This Recipe

White plate with fusilli pasta in a creamy pumpkin sauce. Crisp sage on top with a fork resting into pasta.

Creamy Butternut Squash Pasta

Sweet, roasted butternut squash is blended into the dreamiest velvety sauce. Colorful, cozy and perfect for the Fall but in truth I make this all year round!

Make This Recipe

Linguine in a creamy lemon sauce. Charred lemon slices to left and a fork twirling into noodles at right.

Creamy Lemon Pasta

A bright, zingy cream sauce that feels lighter than most but just as delicious. Fresh lemon cuts through the richness and makes this one incredibly moreish.

Make This Recipe

Creamy Sausage Pasta

A reader and personal favorite! Golden toasted sausage mixed into a light creamy parmesan sauce with onions and herbs. Simple enough for a weeknight but impressive enough for guests!

Make This Recipe

Creamy Pea Pasta with Pancetta

Crispy pancetta, sweet peas, and a silky cream sauce come together for the perfect balance of salty and fresh. A simple combination that never disappoints!

Make This Recipe

Creamy Caramelized Leek Pasta

Soft, caramelized leeks melt into a subtly sweet, ultra creamy sauce. It’s delicate, elegant, and a gorgeous vegetarian option.

Make This Recipe

Creamy Pesto Chicken Pasta

Juicy chicken and basil pesto are folded into a smooth and creamy sauce for the ultimate green comfort pasta. Easy, flavorful, and always a hit.

Make This Recipe

Creamy Roast Garlic Pasta

Slow roasted garlic transforms into a nutty, mellow cream sauce lifted with fresh lemon. Extra silky, deeply flavorful, and one of the most comforting pastas you can make.

Make This Recipe

Creamy Chicken and Mushroom Pasta

The best of both worlds, golden chicken and caramelized mushrooms in a rich, velvety cream sauce. Hearty, comforting and just all round delicious.

Make This Recipe

Tips for the perfect creamy pasta sauce

Keep your heat low.
When adding cream, you never want it at a boil, just the gentlest simmer. This prevents splitting and stops the sauce from becoming too thick.

Use very finely grated Parmesan.
The Parmesan needs to be so finely grated to melt into the cream smoothly. A microplane is great or the star side of a box grater. Do not use pre-shredded cheese, it is full of additives that prevent a smooth melt.

Undercook your pasta by a minute.
Finish the pasta in the sauce so it absorbs the flavor and helps the sauce thicken and cling properly.

Make it saucier than you think.
Creamy sauces always thicken as they cool. Keep it slightly looser in the pan so it’s perfect by the time it hits the table.

Adding lemon juice into a creamy sauce.
Lemon cuts through the richness beautifully, but always keep the heat low when adding it. Stir it in quickly, or add it right at the end with the pasta if you’re worried about curdling.

I hope you found a new creamy pasta recipe to fall in love with. Whether you’re craving something light and lemony or rich and mushroomy, these sauces are all tested, reliable, and perfect for weeknights. Happy cooking!